Chapter 28
How To Write A Filter

This purpose of this chapter is help developers create their own filter (process object). This chapter is divided into four major parts. An initial definition of terms is followed by an overview of the filter creation process. Next, data streaming is discussed. The way data is streamed in ITK must be understood in order to write correct filters. Finally, a section on multithreading describes what you must do in order to take advantage of shared memory parallel processing.

28.1 Terminology

The following is some basic terminology for the discussion that follows. Chapter 3 provides additional background information.

28.2 Overview of Filter Creation

PIC

Filters are defined with respect to the type of data they input (if any), and the type of data they output (if any). The key to writing a ITK filter is to identify the number and types of input and output. Having done so, there are often superclasses that simplify this task via class derivation. For example, most filters in ITK take a single image as input, and produce a single image on output. The superclass itk::ImageToImageFilter is a convenience class that provide most of the functionality needed for such a filter.

Some common base classes for new filters include:

Once the appropriate superclass is identified, the filter writer implements the class defining the methods required by most all ITK objects: New(), PrintSelf(), and protected constructor, copy constructor, delete, and operator=, and so on. Also, don’t forget standard typedefs like Self, Superclass, Pointer, and ConstPointer. Then the filter writer can focus on the most important parts of the implementation: defining the API, data members, and other implementation details of the algorithm. In particular, the filter writer will have to implement either a GenerateData() (non-threaded) or ThreadedGenerateData() method. (See Section 3.2.7 for an overview of multi-threading in ITK.)

An important note: the GenerateData() method is required to allocate memory for the output. The ThreadedGenerateData() method is not. In default implementation (see itk::ImageSource , a superclass of itk::ImageToImageFilter ) GenerateData() allocates memory and then invokes ThreadedGenerateData().

One of the most important decisions that the developer must make is whether the filter can stream data; that is, process just a portion of the input to produce a portion of the output. Often superclass behavior works well: if the filter processes the input using single pixel access, then the default behavior is adequate. If not, then the user may have to a) find a more specialized superclass to derive from, or b) override one or more methods that control how the filter operates during pipeline execution. The next section describes these methods.

28.3 Streaming Large Data

The data associated with multi-dimensional images is large and becoming larger. This trend is due to advances in scanning resolution, as well as increases in computing capability. Any practical segmentation and registration software system must address this fact in order to be useful in application. ITK addresses this problem via its data streaming facility.

In ITK, streaming is the process of dividing data into pieces, or regions, and then processing this data through the data pipeline. Recall that the pipeline consists of process objects that generate data objects, connected into a pipeline topology. The input to a process object is a data object (unless the process initiates the pipeline and then it is a source process object). These data objects in turn are consumed by other process objects, and so on, until a directed graph of data flow is constructed. Eventually the pipeline is terminated by one or more mappers, that may write data to storage, or interface with a graphics or other system. This is illustrated in figures ?? and 28.1.

A significant benefit of this architecture is that the relatively complex process of managing pipeline execution is designed into the system. This means that keeping the pipeline up to date, executing only those portions of the pipeline that have changed, multithreading execution, managing memory allocation, and streaming is all built into the architecture. However, these features do introduce complexity into the system, the bulk of which is seen by class developers. The purpose of this chapter is to describe the pipeline execution process in detail, with a focus on data streaming.

28.3.1 Overview of Pipeline Execution

The pipeline execution process performs several important functions.


PIC

Figure 28.1: The Data Pipeline


  1. It determines which filters, in a pipeline of filters, need to execute. This prevents redundant execution and minimizes overall execution time.
  2. It initializes the (filter’s) output data objects, preparing them for new data. In addition, it determines how much memory each filter must allocate for its output, and allocates it.
  3. The execution process determines how much data a filter must process in order to produce an output of sufficient size for downstream filters; it also takes into account any limits on memory or special filter requirements. Other factors include the size of data processing kernels, that affect how much data input data (extra padding) is required.
  4. It subdivides data into subpieces for multithreading. (Note that the division of data into subpieces is exactly same problem as dividing data into pieces for streaming; hence multithreading comes for free as part of the streaming architecture.)
  5. It may free (or release) output data if filters no longer need it to compute, and the user requests that data is to be released. (Note: a filter’s output data object may be considered a “cache”. If the cache is allowed to remain (ReleaseDataFlagOff()) between pipeline execution, and the filter, or the input to the filter, never changes, then process objects downstream of the filter just reuse the filter’s cache to re-execute.)

To perform these functions, the execution process negotiates with the filters that define the pipeline. Only each filter can know how much data is required on input to produce a particular output. For example, a shrink filter with a shrink factor of two requires an image twice as large (in terms of its x-y dimensions) on input to produce a particular size output. An image convolution filter would require extra input (boundary padding) depending on the size of the convolution kernel. Some filters require the entire input to produce an output (for example, a histogram), and have the option of requesting the entire input. (In this case streaming does not work unless the developer creates a filter that can request multiple pieces, caching state between each piece to assemble the final output.)


PIC

Figure 28.2: Sequence of the Data Pipeline updating mechanism


Ultimately the negotiation process is controlled by the request for data of a particular size (i.e., region). It may be that the user asks to process a region of interest within a large image, or that memory limitations result in processing the data in several pieces. For example, an application may compute the memory required by a pipeline, and then use itk::StreamingImageFilter to break the data processing into several pieces. The data request is propagated through the pipeline in the upstream direction, and the negotiation process configures each filter to produce output data of a particular size.

The secret to creating a streaming filter is to understand how this negotiation process works, and how to override its default behavior by using the appropriate virtual functions defined in itk::ProcessObject . The next section describes the specifics of these methods, and when to override them. Examples are provided along the way to illustrate concepts.

28.3.2 Details of Pipeline Execution

Typically pipeline execution is initiated when a process object receives the ProcessObject::Update() method invocation. This method is simply delegated to the output of the filter, invoking the DataObject::Update() method. Note that this behavior is typical of the interaction between ProcessObject and DataObject: a method invoked on one is eventually delegated to the other. In this way the data request from the pipeline is propagated upstream, initiating data flow that returns downstream.

The DataObject::Update() method in turn invokes three other methods:

28.3.2.1 UpdateOutputInformation()

The UpdateOutputInformation() method determines the pipeline modified time. It may set the RequestedRegion and the LargestPossibleRegion depending on how the filters are configured. (The RequestedRegion is set to process all the data, i.e., the LargestPossibleRegion, if it has not been set.) The UpdateOutputInformation() propagates upstream through the entire pipeline and terminates at the sources.

During UpdateOutputInformation(), filters have a chance to override the ProcessObject::GenerateOutputInformation() method (GenerateOutputInformation() is invoked by UpdateOutputInformation()). The default behavior is for the GenerateOutputInformation() to copy the metadata describing the input to the output (via DataObject::CopyInformation()). Remember, information is metadata describing the output, such as the origin, spacing, and LargestPossibleRegion (i.e., largest possible size) of an image.

A good example of this behavior is itk::ShrinkImageFilter . This filter takes an input image and shrinks it by some integral value. The result is that the spacing and LargestPossibleRegion of the output will be different to that of the input. Thus, GenerateOutputInformation() is overloaded.

28.3.2.2 PropagateRequestedRegion()

The PropagateRequestedRegion() call propagates upstream to satisfy a data request. In typical application this data request is usually the LargestPossibleRegion, but if streaming is necessary, or the user is interested in updating just a portion of the data, the RequestedRegion may be any valid region within the LargestPossibleRegion.

The function of PropagateRequestedRegion() is, given a request for data (the amount is specified by RequestedRegion), propagate upstream configuring the filter’s input and output process object’s to the correct size. Eventually, this means configuring the BufferedRegion, that is the amount of data actually allocated.

The reason for the buffered region is this: the output of a filter may be consumed by more than one downstream filter. If these consumers each request different amounts of input (say due to kernel requirements or other padding needs), then the upstream, generating filter produces the data to satisfy both consumers, that may mean it produces more data than one of the consumers needs.

The ProcessObject::PropagateRequestedRegion() method invokes three methods that the filter developer may choose to overload.

itk::RGBGibbsPriorFilter is an example of a filter that needs to invoke EnlargeOutputRequestedRegion(). The designer of this filter decided that the filter should operate on all the data. Note that a subtle interplay between this method and GenerateInputRequestedRegion() is occurring here. The default behavior of GenerateInputRequestedRegion() (at least for itk::ImageToImageFilter ) is to set the input RequestedRegion to the output’s ReqestedRegion. Hence, by overriding the method EnlargeOutputRequestedRegion() to set the output to the LargestPossibleRegion, effectively sets the input to this filter to the LargestPossibleRegion (and probably causing all upstream filters to process their LargestPossibleRegion as well. This means that the filter, and therefore the pipeline, does not stream. This could be fixed by reimplementing the filter with the notion of streaming built in to the algorithm.)

itk::GradientMagnitudeImageFilter is an example of a filter that needs to invoke GenerateInputRequestedRegion(). It needs a larger input requested region because a kernel is required to compute the gradient at a pixel. Hence the input needs to be “padded out” so the filter has enough data to compute the gradient at each output pixel.

28.3.2.3 UpdateOutputData()

UpdateOutputData() is the third and final method as a result of the Update() method. The purpose of this method is to determine whether a particular filter needs to execute in order to bring its output up to date. (A filter executes when its GenerateData() method is invoked.) Filter execution occurs when a) the filter is modified as a result of modifying an instance variable; b) the input to the filter changes; c) the input data has been released; or d) an invalid RequestedRegion was set previously and the filter did not produce data. Filters execute in order in the downstream direction. Once a filter executes, all filters downstream of it must also execute.

DataObject::UpdateOutputData() is delegated to the DataObject’s source (i.e., the ProcessObject that generated it) only if the DataObject needs to be updated. A comparison of modified time, pipeline time, release data flag, and valid requested region is made. If any one of these conditions indicate that the data needs regeneration, then the source’s ProcessObject::UpdateOutputData() is invoked. These calls are made recursively up the pipeline until a source filter object is encountered, or the pipeline is determined to be up to date and valid. At this point, the recursion unrolls, and the execution of the filter proceeds. (This means that the output data is initialized, StartEvent is invoked, the filters GenerateData() is called, EndEvent is invoked, and input data to this filter may be released, if requested. In addition, this filter’s InformationTime is updated to the current time.)

The developer will never override UpdateOutputData(). The developer need only write the GenerateData() method (non-threaded) or ThreadedGenerateData() method. A discussion of threading follows in the next section.

28.4 Threaded Filter Execution

Filters that can process data in pieces can typically multi-process using the data parallel, shared memory implementation built into the pipeline execution process. To create a multithreaded filter, simply define and implement a ThreadedGenerateData() method. For example, a itk::ImageToImageFilter would create the method:

    void ThreadedGenerateData(const OutputImageRegionType&  
                              outputRegionForThread, itk::ThreadIdType threadId)

The key to threading is to generate output for the output region given (as the first parameter in the argument list above). In ITK, this is simple to do because an output iterator can be created using the region provided. Hence the output can be iterated over, accessing the corresponding input pixels as necessary to compute the value of the output pixel.

Multi-threading requires caution when performing I/O (including using cout or cerr) or invoking events. A safe practice is to allow only thread id zero to perform I/O or generate events. (The thread id is passed as argument into ThreadedGenerateData()). If more than one thread tries to write to the same place at the same time, the program can behave badly, and possibly even deadlock or crash.

28.5 Filter Conventions

In order to fully participate in the ITK pipeline, filters are expected to follow certain conventions, and provide certain interfaces. This section describes the minimum requirements for a filter to integrate into the ITK framework.

The class declaration for a filter should include the macro ITK_EXPORT, so that on certain platforms an export declaration can be included.

A filter should define public types for the class itself (Self) and its Superclass, and const and non-const smart pointers, thus:

  typedef ExampleImageFilter                Self;  
  typedef ImageToImageFilter<TImage,TImage> Superclass;  
  typedef SmartPointer<Self>                Pointer;  
  typedef SmartPointer<const Self>          ConstPointer;

The Pointer type is particularly useful, as it is a smart pointer that will be used by all client code to hold a reference-counted instantiation of the filter.

Once the above types have been defined, you can use the following convenience macros, which permit your filter to participate in the object factory mechanism, and to be created using the canonical ::New():

  /⋆⋆ Method for creation through the object factory. ⋆/  
  itkNewMacro(Self);  
 
  /⋆⋆ Run-time type information (and related methods). ⋆/  
  itkTypeMacro(ExampleImageFilter, ImageToImageFilter);

The default constructor should be protected, and provide sensible defaults (usually zero) for all parameters. The copy constructor and assignment operator should be declared private and not implemented, to prevent instantiating the filter without the factory methods (above).

Finally, the template implementation code (in the .txx file) should be included, bracketed by a test for manual instantiation, thus:

#ifndef ITK_MANUAL_INSTANTIATION  
#include "itkExampleFilter.txx"  
#endif

28.5.1 Optional

A filter can be printed to an std::ostream (such as std::cout) by implementing the following method:

  void PrintSelf( std::ostream& os, Indent indent ) const;

and writing the name-value pairs of the filter parameters to the supplied output stream. This is particularly useful for debugging.

28.5.2 Useful Macros

Many convenience macros are provided by ITK, to simplify filter coding. Some of these are described below:

itkStaticConstMacro
Declares a static variable of the given type, with the specified initial value.
itkGetMacro
Defines an accessor method for the specified scalar data member. The convention is for data members to have a prefix of m_.
itkSetMacro
Defines a mutator method for the specified scalar data member, of the supplied type. This will automatically set the Modified flag, so the filter stage will be executed on the next Update().
itkBooleanMacro
Defines a pair of OnFlag and OffFlag methods for a boolean variable m_Flag.
itkGetObjectMacro, itkSetObjectMacro
Defines an accessor and mutator for an ITK object. The Get form returns a smart pointer to the object.

Much more useful information can be learned from browsing the source in Code/Common/itkMacro.h and for the itk::Object and itk::LightObject classes.

28.6 How To Write A Composite Filter

In general, most ITK/OTB filters implement one particular algorithm, whether it be image filtering, an information metric, or a segmentation algorithm. In the previous section, we saw how to write new filters from scratch. However, it is often very useful to be able to make a new filter by combining two or more existing filters, which can then be used as a building block in a complex pipeline. This approach follows the Composite pattern [48], whereby the composite filter itself behaves just as a regular filter, providing its own (potentially higher level) interface and using other filters (whose detail is hidden to users of the class) for the implementation. This composite structure is shown in Figure 28.3, where the various Stage-n filters are combined into one by the Composite filter. The Source and Sink filters only see the interface published by the Composite. Using the Composite pattern, a composite filter can encapsulate a pipeline of arbitrary complexity. These can in turn be nested inside other pipelines.


PIC

Figure 28.3: A Composite filter encapsulates a number of other filters.


28.6.1 Implementing a Composite Filter

There are a few considerations to take into account when implementing a composite filter. All the usual requirements for filters apply (as discussed above), but the following guidelines should be considered:

  1. The template arguments it takes must be sufficient to instantiate all of the component filters. Each component filter needs a type supplied by either the implementor or the enclosing class. For example, an ImageToImageFilter normally takes an input and output image type (which may be the same). But if the output of the composite filter is a classified image, we need to either decide on the output type inside the composite filter, or restrict the choices of the user when she/he instantiates the filter.
  2. The types of the component filters should be declared in the header, preferably with protected visibility. This is because the internal structure normally should not be visible to users of the class, but should be to descendent classes that may need to modify or customize the behavior.
  3. The component filters should be private data members of the composite class, as in FilterType::Pointer.
  4. The default constructor should build the pipeline by creating the stages and connect them together, along with any default parameter settings, as appropriate.
  5. The input and output of the composite filter need to be grafted on to the head and tail (respectively) of the component filters.

This grafting process is illustrated in Figure 28.4.

28.6.2 A Simple Example


PIC

Figure 28.4: Example of a typical composite filter. Note that the output of the last filter in the internal pipeline must be grafted into the output of the composite filter.


The source code for this example can be found in the file
Examples/Filtering/CompositeFilterExample.cxx.

The composite filter we will build combines three filters: a gradient magnitude operator, which will calculate the first-order derivative of the image; a thresholding step to select edges over a given strength; and finally a rescaling filter, to ensure the resulting image data is visible by scaling the intensity to the full spectrum of the output image type.

Since this filter takes an image and produces another image (of identical type), we will specialize the ImageToImageFilter:

Next we include headers for the component filters:

#include "itkUnaryFunctorImageFilter.h" 
#include "itkGradientMagnitudeImageFilter.h" 
#include "itkThresholdImageFilter.h" 
#include "itkRescaleIntensityImageFilter.h"

Now we can declare the filter itself. It is within the OTB namespace, and we decide to make it use the same image type for both input and output, thus the template declaration needs only one parameter. Deriving from ImageToImageFilter provides default behavior for several important aspects, notably allocating the output image (and making it the same dimensions as the input).

namespace otb 
{ 
 
template <class TImageType> 
class ITK_EXPORT CompositeExampleImageFilter : 
  public itk::ImageToImageFilter<TImageType, TImageType> 
{ 
public:

Next we have the standard declarations, used for object creation with the object factory:

  typedef CompositeExampleImageFilter                     Self; 
  typedef itk::ImageToImageFilter<TImageType, TImageType> Superclass; 
  typedef itk::SmartPointer<Self>                         Pointer; 
  typedef itk::SmartPointer<const Self>                   ConstPointer;

Here we declare an alias (to save typing) for the image’s pixel type, which determines the type of the threshold value. We then use the convenience macros to define the Get and Set methods for this parameter.

  typedef typename TImageType::PixelType PixelType; 
 
  itkGetMacro(Threshold, PixelType); 
  itkSetMacro(Threshold, PixelType);

Now we can declare the component filter types, templated over the enclosing image type:

protected: 
 
  typedef itk::ThresholdImageFilter<TImageType> ThresholdType; 
  typedef itk::GradientMagnitudeImageFilter<TImageType, TImageType> 
  GradientType; 
  typedef itk::RescaleIntensityImageFilter<TImageType, TImageType> 
  RescalerType;

The component filters are declared as data members, all using the smart pointer types.

  typename GradientType::Pointer m_GradientFilter; 
  typename ThresholdType::Pointer m_ThresholdFilter; 
  typename RescalerType::Pointer m_RescaleFilter; 
 
  PixelType m_Threshold; 
}; 
 
} /⋆ namespace otb ⋆/

The constructor sets up the pipeline, which involves creating the stages, connecting them together, and setting default parameters.

template <class TImageType> 
CompositeExampleImageFilter<TImageType> 
::CompositeExampleImageFilter() 
{ 
  m_GradientFilter = GradientType::New(); 
  m_ThresholdFilter = ThresholdType::New(); 
  m_RescaleFilter = RescalerType::New(); 
 
  m_ThresholdFilter->SetInput(m_GradientFilter->GetOutput()); 
  m_RescaleFilter->SetInput(m_ThresholdFilter->GetOutput()); 
 
  m_Threshold = 1; 
 
  m_RescaleFilter->SetOutputMinimum( 
    itk::NumericTraits<PixelType>::NonpositiveMin()); 
  m_RescaleFilter->SetOutputMaximum(itk::NumericTraits<PixelType>::max()); 
}

The GenerateData() is where the composite magic happens. First, we connect the first component filter to the inputs of the composite filter (the actual input, supplied by the upstream stage). Then we graft the output of the last stage onto the output of the composite, which ensures the filter regions are updated. We force the composite pipeline to be processed by calling Update() on the final stage, then graft the output back onto the output of the enclosing filter, so it has the result available to the downstream filter.

template <class TImageType> 
void 
CompositeExampleImageFilter<TImageType>:: 
GenerateData() 
{ 
  m_GradientFilter->SetInput(this->GetInput()); 
 
  m_ThresholdFilter->ThresholdBelow(this->m_Threshold); 
 
  m_RescaleFilter->GraftOutput(this->GetOutput()); 
  m_RescaleFilter->Update(); 
  this->GraftOutput(m_RescaleFilter->GetOutput()); 
}

Finally we define the PrintSelf method, which (by convention) prints the filter parameters. Note how it invokes the superclass to print itself first, and also how the indentation prefixes each line.

template <class TImageType> 
void 
CompositeExampleImageFilter<TImageType>:: 
PrintSelf(std::ostream& os, itk::Indent indent) const 
{ 
  Superclass::PrintSelf(os, indent); 
 
  os 
  << indent << "Threshold:" << this->m_Threshold 
  << std::endl; 
} 
 
} /⋆ end namespace otb ⋆/

It is important to note that in the above example, none of the internal details of the pipeline were exposed to users of the class. The interface consisted of the Threshold parameter (which happened to change the value in the component filter) and the regular ImageToImageFilter interface. This example pipeline is illustrated in Figure 28.4.